Wednesday, June 29, 2011

Choosing to Parent by Adoption and Donor Insemination: The Differences

Choosing to Parent by Adoption and Donor Insemination:  The Differences
By Linda Kingston

     This is my opinion about the differences in becoming a parent through adoption vs. sperm donor conception.   The primary differences are legal issues, social acceptance, the amount of control the parents have, and the intention of the parents.  There are many variables in adoption and each story is different, so some of these issues do not apply to all adoptions.

     I have long been a supporter of family planning services.  Long before I chose to adopt a child, I donated money to international family planning organizations.  Now I volunteer for a family planning agency and continue to donate money.

     My husband and I have two children who are biological sisters.  They were adopted from Guatemala at ages 6 months and 8 months.  We have an open adoption with their birthmother Anna and her extended family. 

Here are the primary differences:

1)       Control and intention

     Adoption is about making the best of a difficult situation, and is never a first choice when practiced legally and ethically.   In an ideal world, only married couples would conceive children who are planned and wanted. Conception under these conditions is the best way to ensure a child will not be placed for adoption.  Anna tried her best to conceive her children under ideal circumstances, but due to lack of resources and education it didn’t happen.   I also tried my best to prevent the adoption by donating money to international family planning organizations. 

     In an ideal world, adoption wouldn’t exist.  I would be sad that I could not adopt a child, but also happy that all children could be cared for by their biological family.  Back to reality; it isn’t a perfect world, and that is why adoption exists.    

     Despite my best efforts, Anna had an unplanned pregnancy.  I did the best I could to prevent it.  My decision to adopt and Anna’s decision to place a child for adoption were two separate events.  Anna placed her children for adoption because of her difficult life circumstances, and not because I wanted to be a parent.    

     Legal and ethical adoption starts with the needs of a child, but DI starts with the desires of adults.  Is it fair for the parents raising the child to expect the donor to make sacrifices so they can have the privilege of being a parent?  Is it fair for a man to donate sperm even though this decision could be painful for the child?  Is it fair for parents to ask their children to sacrifice by bringing them into the world under complex and painful circumstances?  My answer to these questions is “No”.
2)       Cultural acceptance

     Adoption is viewed much more positively in our society than conception by sperm donor.  This can affect the way a child accepts himself.  Advice columnist Dr. Laura Schlessinger said “There is no pride in being conceived by a man who ejaculates into a cup.”    

3)       Legal issues.

     In the USA, all children accept those conceived by sperm donor or other 3rd party reproduction have the legal right to two parents.  For children conceived the old-fashioned way, the biological father is required to support the child whether he likes it or not.  This is because the needs of the child are more important than the adult’s.   However, with sperm donation the decision to deny the child a legal biological father is made even before the child is conceived.

     I realize that many single women and lesbian couples who conceive by DI are financially stable and mature people, and they often don’t need financial help from a Dad. However, that is irrelevant.   Children conceived by DI deserve the same rights as children conceived the old-fashioned way.  

     There are adoption laws to protect children and their biological parents from unethical practices, although like any laws they don’t always work.  At least the laws exist and society recognizes that children and their biological parents have human and legal rights.  Unfortunately, the same cannot be said for donor insemination.  Parents who conceive a child by DI make a deliberate choice to deny a child their rights.    

     Sperm donors are paid.  Money influences his decision to donate.  This is a decision that might cause him and his family pain, but there are no laws requiring donors to receive counseling.  In adoption it is illegal to make payments to birthparents for unnecessary expenses because it might influence their decision.  The laws don’t always work, but at least the laws exist.  In DI, there are no laws to protect the donor from the influence of money.

     For parents who chose to conceive a child by DI, there is no law requiring counseling to be sure they understand this very complex and potentially painful way of becoming a parent.  That isn’t fair to the parent or the child. In adoption, the parents are required to learn about adoption through counseling, classes, home studies, and reading.

Adoption is not perfect, but it is a better choice than conceiving a child by DI.


  1. I really appreciate you for posting this great blog. There are several ways to conceive a child, and there are factors to consider before you choose one, out of which the rate of artificial insemination success is an important one.

    Hospitals specializing in Artificial Insemination in Israel

  2. Thanks for great information you write it very clean. I am very lucky to get this tips from you

    Sperm Donor Glasgow

  3. Hi Linda,
    I'm Alana S., I run the site.
    I wanted to say thanks for submitting to me the link to your blog. I wanted to tell you though that I can't accept direct links to blogs and non-anonymous writing. It violates the vibe of the site. So all the stories I accept have to be of a certain length and character, and all of the authors must be anonymous.
    However I have accepted pieces that have been published elsewhere and simply re-submitted to me without an author's signature. And so if you wanted to do that I would be A okay with it.

    But I really do appreciate you coming to the site and participating.
    Also, love the writing!

    all the best,

  4. This is very good information.i think it's useful advice. really nice blog. keep it up!!!

    - sperm donor

  5. There are many avenues to choosing a sperm donor, so before making that crucial decision, consider all the different aspects and chose the rigth and credible person.

  6. If anyone want sperm donation then contact me on 09650038357 i live in gurgaon and i can come in delhi also for donation but i want some money for donation i will keep it private and secret

  7. Hi

    If you are trying to get pregnant naturally, you must read this writing!

    Last week, I came across this incredible holistic pregnancy program written by a nutritionist and a health consultant. Her name is Lisa Olson.

    Lisa has the incredible ability to cut through all the BS and hype that surrounds overcoming infertility and getting pregnant naturally.

    Do you want to learn how to get pregnant and give birth to healthy children from someone who has herself cured her infertility (and coached many women in reversing infertility issues), or from someone who just read about how to get pregnant?

    Sorry, but experience wins out in my book. I will always want to learn from the person who's actually done what I'm trying to do.

    If you're battling with any type infertility or are struggling to get pregnant especially if you're on your late 30's or late 40's, you MUST check this out --

    I don't endorse many products. Mainly because they are mostly hype and don't live up to expectation. Lisa's new book called "Pregnancy Miracle", is an exception! This material is excellent and a MUST READ for anyone trying to get pregnant naturally and dramatically improve their health and well-being.

    Click the link below to read more about this fantastic book and how it can help you achieve your goals:

    >>>>> How To Treat infertility <<<<<


    Now, I know many of you are saying, "Oh no, not another 'get pregnant in 7 days' program". To be totally honest, I thought the same thing. Rest assured, this is not the case. It is not a quick fix, or gimmick. Its 250+ pages of solid, clinically proven holistic information for getting pregnant. She starts from square one and teaches you everything you need to know. Doesn't matter what type of infertility you have and regardless of your age or lifestyle, you WILL learn something from this book.

    Here's what the author Lisa Olson had to say about her incredible program:

    "After 14 years of trial, error and experimentation, I finally discovered the answer to infertility and developed a fool-proof system to getting pregnant the natural way - no drugs, or surgery necessary. And now I'm finally revealing my secrets in this new 'encyclopedia' of pregnancy called, Pregnancy Miracle.

    I will be your own personal coach, take you by the hand, and lead you through the lousy advice, hype and gimmicks...and directly to the sort of inner balance perfection that will end your battle with infertility forever and help you become a proud mother of your healthy children.

    Don't even THINK about buying any pregnancy or infertility product, drugs or going on a gimmick pregnancy program until you read my revealing, no-holds barred holistic getting pregnant book..."

    Click the link below to read more: Get Pregnant Naturally